Women’s Day - A Sham
March 10, 2008 by Team ASO
Vivek Bala
Its that time of the year, Women’s day or is it Woman’s Day? Seems like there is a coterie of women who flaunt themselves before the media every year for ‘the cause of women’. Funny thing is that, invariably it is the same coterie again and again every year. Any social event for Women’s day is marked by appearances by ‘Women who achieved great things in Society’ like Preity Zinta, Nita Ambani, Smita Thackerey, Sharmila Tagore, Sweta Nanda Bachchan, Ekta Kapoor and so on. Now these faces will be the ones repeatedly shown with gleaming smiles, showering praises on the ‘Woman of Today’. Aah…one must really applaud them for their efforts. You know why?
Nita Ambani - Wife of India’s richest man, Mukesh Ambani. Was gifted a 240 crore Jet by her husband! They have so much wealth that they need to buy just to avoid taxes! Now, with so much of money at your disposal, you wouldn’t expect the lady to be at home making roti and dal. After all, you can’t be always called the Wife of Mukesh Ambani with no identity of yourself. So what do you do? You indulge in media watched charity. Now charity is good no doubts but does it involve any sort of labour or effort on this lady’s side? She has money that she doesn’t know what to do with. She just has to dispose them and hell! she gets awarded for that!
Priety Zinta - She made only one movie last year and that too flopped badly at the box office. An affair with Ness Wadia, the heir of the Wadia group would only mean social status and money. More glamour, more media outings, more media glare. Crores being spent on their IPL team, Chandigarh and all whose money? Well, investors, Wadia group etc…What did she have to do? Wear big sunglasses and power suits and talk to the media as if they have just conquered Mars.
Ekta Kapoor - Daughter of Jitendra ‘Jumping Jack’ - lots of family money. I don’t say she has not become the boss of Indian Television out of nothing. She has done her bit of hard work. But then, give me all the backing her father gave in terms of finance and contacts and i would have achieved the same.
The other women you guys should know. Sweta Nanda Bachchan, the daughter of the biggest superstar of Indian Cinema, Amitabh Bachchan and wife of Nikhil Nanda (grandson of Raj Kapoor). Do I even need to comment? Smita Thackerey, the Daughter-in-law of Shiv Sena supremo, Bal Thackerey has so much power at her disposal that big cinema stars stoop to being servile before her. See filmfare award functions and every single award recipient would thank her for achieving the award! Beats me! How is Smita Thackerey involved in their achieving an award?? Sharmila Tagore, needless to say was and has always been in an environment of prosperity. One should see the horse races she and her husband, the Nawab of Pataudi indulge in.
So, looking at all these, one wonders….”where is the real woman of India”? One who languishes behind veils, one who works day in and day out in households as a maid earning as little as youngsters like me spend on coke a month. Where is the woman struggling in construction sites carrying heavy loads, facing abuses of fellow men and making sure her kids have a meal to eat everyday? Where is the woman who is struggling to create an identity for herself when she tries to get a job as conductor or a driver of a bus in a highly male domain. Where is that woman who sells Idlys to make her son study at IIM?
More and more women opt for divorce and many indulge in extra marital affairs says the newspaper. The changing face of the modern woman it says. Boldness they say. Is boldness all about snapping relations and being infidel? Is that all that is there to a woman? Does breaking the bastions of a male dominated society mean infidelity and intolerance to relations? Is the partying, boozing woman of today the new face of women?
There are women out there who break all odds to bring their family out of poverty by making remarkable achievements like the World Carrom Champion Ilavazhagi for whom everyday survival is a battle. They have to literally plead for attention whereas the rest, affluent go away with all laurels and applauds. Who is the real achiever? The lady who despite her husband’s demise, makes a good citizen of her son; the lady who sustains various complexities of her in laws and still manages to keep the family in one piece. Let us salute that woman and value her and not make a mockery of ‘Women’s Day’.
Every day is to be a woman’s day. They, as humans have equal right as all men. They have equal share in enjoying life as much as men do. The whole concept of a Women’s day is a sham when political parties come out asking for a reservation for women in the parliament for reasons only they know. Why should transport authorities have women drivers only on Women’s day? Why should Kingfisher Airlines and Air India have an all women crew only on this day? It is like saying, “Ok thank you for giving this day exclusively for us. The rest of the year is for you men”. Let us stop demeaning women with such a ‘Day’.
Good one…. I totally agree…. Reservations, women’s day celebration, speeches on women’s rights, feminist talk shows and debates are what actually discriminating women.
We don’t want to be celebrated, neither do we want to be degraded.
Hi Vivek,
Fully agree with your points. A very realistic analysis on women role models which our media champion & want us to believe. Good work!
True…these people are not the true icons….they are brand glamours..
Let me name a few great women i agree are the icons.
1. Salu marada Thimakka - one who planted the Salu mara (Salu tree) all along the roadside to help green awareness.
2. Medha Patkar - going all over the nation to side with farmers and women destitues….Now dont brand her a communist
3. Ilavazhagi - World Carrom Champion.
4. That great mom who sat next to our Chief justice of the Supreme Court, Mr. K.G.Balakrishnan, when he took oath.
Thanks for gifting India such a great person ma. Every other mother struggling hard with work and family.
4. Indian Women working in the fields while also cooking after the days work.
These women are the real champions…
I do agree. It’s become commercialised, the media, and the business - archies, jewellery shops, the clothes store, the movie stars all take the limelight.
The real achievers are forgotten. But it sure is good to have a day, if you ask me. Atleast then, the mothers of our kitchen get a good big hug and are taken out for lunch
@ beaulah
uh huh?? so you need a day to be respected like that?? so are you ok with the fact that 364 days of the year you will be abused and taken for granted? come on! dun deamean yourself lady! having a day is like saying that yes, we are down and out and we need to be consoled by men for all the things that we face for the rest of the year. it is like approving the consolation
vinod is absolutely right here..one more woman to be noted is Mukhtar Mai ,
haha, well, u got me wrong. am not asking for a day when only ‘women’ r respected and thereby demeaning women. What am sayin is, its jst another day.
Why do we celebrate a birthday, a mother’s day, a father’s day, valentine day, polio day, a cancer day? Apart from the HYPE the media, and the commercialisation, I guess it does have something to it. I know this is a hot topic to debate on.
But for a moment, remove all the extra effects that the society/media throws upon it and see it as a day, when they ( the topic) are (is) given more thought. Those who are mistreated, those who struggle for a living, those who fight against the evils of the soceity and also those who are silenced by it. I personaly take it as a day, to appreciate the women in my life, those who have helped to reach the place where I am now. I dont think abt them every day. Do u? and in your words ‘Lets salute them, the real achievers’
I guess throwing the light on them on normal days also makes you think.its not that our brains and emotions are switched off for 364 days. when there is something to ponder about, we do it
well , so true and so well expressed . recently after watching aaja nachle , the squib by madhuri and yashraj , someone remarked - madhuri is looking soo goodeven at 42 . i said - give me a couple of crores and in six months i will look even better .
well , that maybe wishful thinking for the most part , but the truth is that yes , money does buy everything . for the rest of us , no recognition . i say , celebrate women who have achieved the ordinary in extraordinary conditions , not women whose brain is forever taxed in making the right handbag choice for the next gala . but on the other hand dont u think these poor rich girls deserve some kudos ?? after all snagging an alpha male MUST take some brains , nah ??